SEO Traffic Analysis: Why Organic Traffic Drops | Brian Kato

With Brian Kato, founder of Fusion Vine · Streamed live · 50 min

What this episode covers

Brian Kato joined the show after the scheduled guest Matthew Millington cancelled due to illness, and the conversation centred on diagnosing organic traffic drops. He argued that marketers should read direct, referral and organic traffic together, track conversions and lead quality rather than visits, and recognise that paid campaigns can lift organic traffic indirectly.

Key takeaways

  • ✦Look at direct and referral traffic alongside organic before concluding that organic traffic has dropped.
  • ✦Track conversions and lead quality, since traffic can fall while lead quality rises.
  • ✦Establish a baseline for normal traffic and run campaigns for a decent amount of time before judging them.
  • ✦Build a test environment site to try tools and strategies before applying them to client sites.
  • ✦Treat paid traffic as a way to reach people whose later search behaviour can boost organic results.

Key moments

  1. 27:36Dark social and direct traffic
    “If you and I are texting back and forth that kind of a referral, that kind of engagement I would come in on analytics as direct traffic.”
  2. 30:30Lead quality versus traffic volume
    “The issue that we're looking at though is traffic has gone down and in some cases we've seen it up to 80% drop.”
  3. 31:23Meta title changes and traffic
    “All I did was change the meta titles of for like 900 pages in my traffic shot up like 200%”
  4. 44:01Meta for demand, Google for closing
    “Meta tends to be demand generation. Google's the closer.”

Quotes are from the episode transcript, lightly cleaned of auto-caption errors.

Questions answered in this episode

Why might organic traffic drop without the SEO work being at fault?
Possible causes include people advertising more, AI overviews taking over clicks, and buyer behaviour shifting away from what the business offers. Dark social in direct traffic can also hide the real source.
Should you judge a paid ad campaign after a week or two?
No, Brian Kato says you should run it for about a month and then see what happens to traffic if you stop, to find out whether it holds.
Can paid traffic improve organic search results?
Brian Kato says tests they ran show paid traffic affects organic, because the engagement and clicks it generates lead to organic gains rather than the ad itself.

More episodes on Links & Digital PR