Google Search Console Anonymous Queries | Matthew Mellinger

With Matthew Mellinger, Owns Local SEO Partners and is a co-founder of SEO Gets · Streamed live · 67 min

What this episode covers

Matthew Mellinger explains that Google Search Console anonymous queries hide long-tail query data, so site owners should rely on first-party data and page-level click trends rather than exact keyword numbers. He demonstrates the SEO Gets tool, which combines multiple Search Console accounts, tracks content groups, and flags striking-distance opportunities. The main conclusion is to judge pages by clicks that drive revenue and to re-optimize or create pages when clicks decline.

Key takeaways

  • ✦Use first-party Search Console and analytics data over third-party keyword estimates for your own site.
  • ✦Treat anonymous queries as an incomplete picture and analyze performance at the page level.
  • ✦Track page-level click trends over time and re-optimize or create a page when clicks decline.
  • ✦Study the top three results for an intent, combine their best parts into a better page, then build links.

Key moments

  1. 25:12What anonymous queries are
    “the Branded search like you will filter by your branded search and it will filter down it'll say there”
  2. 28:40Why page level data matters
    “they don't hide clicks on the page level and so again if you're looking at this and you're saying hey we had a huge in increase in clicks”
  3. 32:27Third-party data versus first-party data
    “search console first- party data is always going to be uh a lot better informed in in that table”
  4. 35:15Re-optimize pages when clicks decline
    “this page needs to either be reoptimized or better serving that intent or I need to go create another page”
  5. 52:21Finding striking distance opportunities
    “I want to find all um queries or keywords that are ranking between four and 20 because I know that”
  6. 1:03:11Advice for aspiring SEOs
    “SEO is very much a try and fail game I've asked people I've respected questions”

Quotes are from the episode transcript, lightly cleaned of auto-caption errors.

Questions answered in this episode

What are anonymous queries in Google Search Console?
Matthew describes them as long-tail queries that are not issued by more than a few dozen users over a two to three month period, so their individual query data is hidden while clicks still appear in totals.
Should I use third-party keyword tools for my own site's click data?
Matthew says third-party tools are for competitor analysis and inspiration, while Search Console and analytics first-party data is better for your own site's page-level and click insights.
Which metric should SEOs track instead of raw clicks?
Matthew argues the key KPI is return on investment, asking whether clicks drive customers that produce revenue, since raw clicks can be vanity metrics.

More episodes on Content & On-Page SEO