Google Search Console Anonymous Queries | Matthew Mellinger
With Matthew Mellinger, Owns Local SEO Partners and is a co-founder of SEO Gets · Streamed live · 67 min
What this episode covers
Matthew Mellinger explains that Google Search Console anonymous queries hide long-tail query data, so site owners should rely on first-party data and page-level click trends rather than exact keyword numbers. He demonstrates the SEO Gets tool, which combines multiple Search Console accounts, tracks content groups, and flags striking-distance opportunities. The main conclusion is to judge pages by clicks that drive revenue and to re-optimize or create pages when clicks decline.
Key takeaways
- ✦Use first-party Search Console and analytics data over third-party keyword estimates for your own site.
- ✦Treat anonymous queries as an incomplete picture and analyze performance at the page level.
- ✦Track page-level click trends over time and re-optimize or create a page when clicks decline.
- ✦Study the top three results for an intent, combine their best parts into a better page, then build links.
Key moments
- 25:12What anonymous queries are
“the Branded search like you will filter by your branded search and it will filter down it'll say there”
- 28:40Why page level data matters
“they don't hide clicks on the page level and so again if you're looking at this and you're saying hey we had a huge in increase in clicks”
- 32:27Third-party data versus first-party data
“search console first- party data is always going to be uh a lot better informed in in that table”
- 35:15Re-optimize pages when clicks decline
“this page needs to either be reoptimized or better serving that intent or I need to go create another page”
- 52:21Finding striking distance opportunities
“I want to find all um queries or keywords that are ranking between four and 20 because I know that”
- 1:03:11Advice for aspiring SEOs
“SEO is very much a try and fail game I've asked people I've respected questions”
Quotes are from the episode transcript, lightly cleaned of auto-caption errors.
Questions answered in this episode
- What are anonymous queries in Google Search Console?
- Matthew describes them as long-tail queries that are not issued by more than a few dozen users over a two to three month period, so their individual query data is hidden while clicks still appear in totals.
- Should I use third-party keyword tools for my own site's click data?
- Matthew says third-party tools are for competitor analysis and inspiration, while Search Console and analytics first-party data is better for your own site's page-level and click insights.
- Which metric should SEOs track instead of raw clicks?
- Matthew argues the key KPI is return on investment, asking whether clicks drive customers that produce revenue, since raw clicks can be vanity metrics.
More episodes on Content & On-Page SEO

Zero-Click Marketing: Influence Before the Click | Amanda Natividad
Amanda Natividad

Content Strategy for Enterprise SEO | Angela Clark Wilson
Angela Clark Wilson

PPC for SEO: Using Paid Data for Keywords | Derek Booth
Derek Booth

B2B Content Marketing: Top-of-Funnel Still Matters | Monty Montgomery
Monty Montgomery

Jobs to Be Done Framework for Marketing | Jordan Fowler
Jordan Fowler

SEO Course for Beginners | Ștefan Prohnițchi
Ștefan Prohnițchi