Online Reputation Management for SEO | Joe Troyer
With Joe Troyer, Internet entrepreneur; founder of Review Grower; host of the Digital Triggers podcast · Streamed live · 63 min
What this episode covers
Joe Troyer explains how online reputation management affects local rankings, covering personal review requests, a one-time catch-up campaign followed by a drip campaign, and monitoring reviews and brand mentions. He also discusses review gating, PR links from sources like HARO and Terkel, and high-DR guest posts for authority. His main conclusion is that reviews are a major local ranking factor and reputation work should be systematic rather than hack-based.
Key takeaways
- ✦Ask for reviews personally from the business owner using a ready-made message, which Joe says gets about 70% response.
- ✦Run a one-time catch-up push for old reviews first, then switch to a drip campaign for new customers.
- ✦Train staff to request feedback during a positive transaction, with a clear reason why it matters to the business.
- ✦Build authority with a few high-DR guest posts and PR links rather than many weak links.
- ✦Know how each review platform handles review gating, since some, like Yelp, are strict about it.
Key moments
- 16:59Introducing Joe Troyer's background
“Joe is an internet entrepreneur helping business make more money since 2005.”
- 25:47Why reviews drive local rankings
“It doesn't matter really where you rank organically, GBP is going to crush that in terms of call volume every time.”
- 31:36Personal spike campaign for reviews
“And the response rate on those to a successful review is like 70%.”
- 32:07Switching to drip campaign later
“then we'll implement whatever everybody else does, right? That drip campaign for new customers”
- 38:01Responding to negative reviews
“let's take care of the customer because if we take care of the customer, then we can often get them to update the review”
- 41:33Review gating and platform policies
“I think that best practice is to know how these platforms handle gating and what their thoughts are”
Quotes are from the episode transcript, lightly cleaned of auto-caption errors.
Questions answered in this episode
- How many people respond to a personal review request?
- Joe says a request sent personally by the owner to people they know gets about a 70% response, while typical drip campaigns get 5 to 15%.
- Should you use review gating?
- Joe says best practice is to know how each platform handles gating, noting Google is not litigious while Yelp takes review blocking and gating seriously.
- How did Review Grower build its domain authority?
- Joe says they went from DR3 to DR66 in 11 months using guest posts on high-DR sites, PR links from HARO and Terkel, and a content team.
More episodes on Local SEO

Local SEO: AI Visibility and Citations | Jordan Pearce
Jordan Pearce

Google Maps Ranking: Near Me Local SEO Strategies | Chris Palmer
Chris Palmer

Local SEO Audits: Entity Gaps and Content Decay | Michael Rayburn
Michael Rayburn

Link Exchange for Local Businesses | David Kaljic
David Kaljic

Local SEO Ranking Factors Reaction | Mike Merlino
Mike Merlino

Property Management SEO Lessons | Ryan Ricketts
Ryan Ricketts