SEO ROI: How to Show SEO Value to Leadership | Will Critchlow
With Will Critchlow, founder of SearchPilot · Streamed live · 64 min
What this episode covers
Will Critchlow explains how SEO professionals can prove SEO's value to leadership by tying work to revenue and the KPIs executives are accountable for. He recommends a plan with a dollar goal, a clear bet and weekly lead metrics, backed by controlled SEO experiments that show impact instead of guesses.
Key takeaways
- ✦Frame SEO work in the revenue and KPIs that leadership is accountable for, not in technical language.
- ✦Write a plan with a dollar-denominated goal, a clear bet, and weekly lead metrics that show whether you are doing the work.
- ✦Prove impact with controlled SEO tests, and document what changed on the website and when.
- ✦Measure success by revenue and traffic quality rather than raw traffic volume.
Key moments
- 20:56Controlled SEO Experiments at SearchPilot
“we run these controlled SEO experiments essentially so very large websites our customers are folks like travel”
- 34:56Connect SEO to Executive KPIs
“you have to tie what you're doing to what they care about and you know typically that's some form of Revenue profit growth”
- 35:52Dollar Goal and Lead Metrics
“you have your big big goal right probably denominated in dollars like I say and then those things that you do those are your lead metrics”
- 45:27Testing Hygiene and Documentation
“a big first step of this is just getting better at documenting what you did to the website when”
- 51:36Prioritizing Hypotheses Under Budget
“you want to classify them into how strong is the hypothesis how confident are we that this is a good idea”
- 56:34Core Updates and Future of Search
“I would put money I am effectively am putting money on uh the core updates becoming an increasingly continuous part”
Quotes are from the episode transcript, lightly cleaned of auto-caption errors.
Questions answered in this episode
- How can SEO professionals get leadership to fund SEO work?
- Critchlow advises connecting work to the executive's objectives and expressing benefits in dollars, backed by a believable plan with measurable lead metrics.
- What is the best way to prove SEO value when you cannot run scientific tests?
- Document what changed on the website and when, and learn from published test results from others, since small sites often cannot run controlled experiments.
- Where can an SEO professional find a company's business objectives?
- Public companies' quarterly earnings reports and earnings calls reveal objectives, and listening to the language executives use helps you reflect it back in your work.
More episodes on Content & On-Page SEO

Zero-Click Marketing: Influence Before the Click | Amanda Natividad
Amanda Natividad

Content Strategy for Enterprise SEO | Angela Clark Wilson
Angela Clark Wilson

PPC for SEO: Using Paid Data for Keywords | Derek Booth
Derek Booth

B2B Content Marketing: Top-of-Funnel Still Matters | Monty Montgomery
Monty Montgomery

Jobs to Be Done Framework for Marketing | Jordan Fowler
Jordan Fowler

SEO Course for Beginners | Ștefan Prohnițchi
Ștefan Prohnițchi